{
  "review_date": "2026-10-15",
  "basis": "原判断—新未知—选择与理由—操作—实际所得—继续／回返",
  "articles": [
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/conception-creation.md",
      "decision": "保留上轮整体重写的职责；复核其上下游链接及术语，与本轮剩余专题接续。",
      "sha256": "c05d08fb0010df1950e44d387b0966dddcf1f73f1406897bd0d5cdd5fee7a85d"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/content-map.md",
      "decision": "补充文章的语义职责及产物交接；去重按职责划界而不按段落相似机械删除。",
      "sha256": "2310ae0c8eaea8e9556482ec847467adeae07f5e22eb4dde563bac8a283afda1"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/context-interpretation.md",
      "decision": "保留上轮整体重写的职责；复核其上下游链接及术语，与本轮剩余专题接续。",
      "sha256": "97b8aa0bbc4b67047c25f385f04f72bb5a33d5df4bc862579d370365a033ad20"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/critique-development.md",
      "decision": "保留上轮整体重写的职责；复核其上下游链接及术语，与本轮剩余专题接续。",
      "sha256": "0796f10c8f81ce00c97da507645a552cd8d41c882c90be9ea6fe5f3d3b6396a0"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/experience-question.md",
      "decision": "删除节点中重复的观察工具表；由照片、竞争解释、下一动作连续形成问题。",
      "sha256": "ea4ab1a04c63fd4b90f2de44c0574b9fb99a8465328f817308b1bf2de8745bca"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/form-relations.md",
      "decision": "节点从并列词汇表改为解释—比较—回到整件作品；具体工具与案例交给唯一专题。",
      "sha256": "06a63b9c5898ada94a053a56e92eb7331cea3f9ed08a50ce13b44d594ae8ab28"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/index.md",
      "decision": "把文章职责与相邻决定加入已有生长规则，不新增节点或另立通用流程。",
      "sha256": "2a2a502789d9042ec655b4625b01cddc6082819f3d5c302c84b98d6010af8fec"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/learning-path.md",
      "decision": "四段责任保留；把P1到P2的抽象阶段接到实际新增的一次目的和取舍。",
      "sha256": "b2238b2b282aea661b7cbb791cb7741da1dfa2a7b6487c6f312149c407d367a8"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/medium-generation.md",
      "decision": "保留上轮整体重写的职责；复核其上下游链接及术语，与本轮剩余专题接续。",
      "sha256": "6d5ffc603e260d884e74fd142bcbdecb5551d6b576846612b96505189c40ed01"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/01-learning/independent-project.md",
      "decision": "过程档案作为通用字段唯一维护处；用同一课题的新增决定解释独立责任，避免把重复练习当递进。",
      "sha256": "2431673938e2ec1eddb3a6bed41ad2ae0510204d52c1db69a820ec4d5b65ba00"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/01-learning/objects-to-inquiry.md",
      "decision": "保留并行新练习：开启、移走、修补围绕实际对象形成比较与下一作品；素材及候选状态清楚，无需套入VI步骤。",
      "sha256": "0571be9913743a94cb0ed657899cc03cf5844be7dfe87da83cac6c1f7ec8bf4d"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/01-learning/relations-to-expression.md",
      "decision": "补足从辨认差别到自选目的的第二轮；已完成VI案例表改为可选对读，练习和学习责任保持主线。",
      "sha256": "a224bae9218217136ce151540fcd647066cc2b371c33fd0a7c35258ea116b94a"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/01-learning/rules-to-practice.md",
      "decision": "保留上轮整体重写的职责；复核其上下游链接及术语，与本轮剩余专题接续。",
      "sha256": "b776657812433a4c3283c701c087602a18aefaed641537fbb43dcb1be9162838"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/02-methods/critique-transfer.md",
      "decision": "保留上轮整体重写的职责；复核其上下游链接及术语，与本轮剩余专题接续。",
      "sha256": "aa2a916173b1d5928137a1d6b06b937261b3a79e4238f15d0c1a47f071a090f0"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/02-methods/index.md",
      "decision": "明确通用方法、品牌路由与制作卡的层次；保留十五个调用入口。",
      "sha256": "5d04d1c3b8ad98047bac8671a5acbb869378dbcb5c065f742bd53ca02440f844"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/02-methods/object-relations.md",
      "decision": "保留并行新方法：由信封属性进入角色、竞争解释及材料／主动规则差异，明确接M06—M10及物件练习。",
      "sha256": "58a92e54bdc1d3ec9e9880d3aa154aa5840ed94aeac2e44fa2092d732d3335d2"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/02-methods/observation-comparison.md",
      "decision": "五件方法由同一比较问题连续分路；删除重复套式输入产物表述，明确方法之间何时切换。",
      "sha256": "2b05b34fcd841592818916e0416d6c13cc4ced5e2e7c6c6f5deb00ea2b60c34b"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/02-methods/translation-generation.md",
      "decision": "把五项生成方法写成从意图、作用、迁移到联合使用的可回返推导；材料所得能改变意图。",
      "sha256": "11a6975bc8efdba0a72b8f2544854a95f217293ecd6a4ba26a6e838ce0d6d4ca"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/03-applications/art-practice.md",
      "decision": "保留：四项课题武器与工作室活动承担艺术实践职责；不覆盖本轮其他工作新增的物件关系入口。",
      "sha256": "86e42e3a7339f9759f4283948eb06013aafa20eefa415384f1b8d1860a8e6df5"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/03-applications/brand-vi.md",
      "decision": "用联合稿变化接到规则和接手，不重复工作台的完整字段清单。",
      "sha256": "ffc1971c85a0f83e5b196dac88b1c04f33ea23ea06a0fda03e221eafa0c4e78d"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/03-applications/digital-surface.md",
      "decision": "由真实Hero的表面、入口、比例和容器串起推导；用前后图替代只有表格的并列入口。",
      "sha256": "76cf158da74cb684b58023fb082ef5ca839ce1833a82cbc4a7ba523323c6e257"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/03-applications/vi-rules-handoff.md",
      "decision": "保留上轮整体重写的职责；复核其上下游链接及术语，与本轮剩余专题接续。",
      "sha256": "10372bbaf6bf4a4a072562c9f39461cf5f92e458b6d645d9804d2c3a6cf058c2"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/aesthetic-experience.md",
      "decision": "保留Clark、复看与美育正文；将重复案例目录改成经验到意味、呈现的明确依赖。",
      "sha256": "8ac1ab0f703c577a93b5271d69692880e99af7ffaadcae3c4a95606f116b2eb2"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-sensory-direction.md",
      "decision": "保留六项具体感知方向与试作；从同一操作分叉到不同体验，把最终纸项目反馈写进原判断，去除三篇基础的重复解说。",
      "sha256": "0387fae98da84fd2705c1314f5ed8f459b97cb58c985b655192090b6708e3fca"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-tone-strategy.md",
      "decision": "由用户关系、环境差异、内容责任和性格冲突逐步建立调性；案例接住前一项未知，制作步骤归操作卡。",
      "sha256": "a1bd4e296129f3fbbc0c4b8fdea5274dd77b3b9c97f2732c5c03b7bb90004364"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-appreciating-method.md",
      "decision": "保留上轮整体重写的职责；复核其上下游链接及术语，与本轮剩余专题接续。",
      "sha256": "62cb35f0094a4023dfc70560a902d4a33db0161374111ac1a87b24478b4e9719"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-asset-derivation.md",
      "decision": "重建由保留依据、同源权限、互补职责到条件联动的推导；合并重复六项步骤到卡片，保留案例事实与使用边界。",
      "sha256": "b47dcba57f56378ade1d480da8ef03a7821d46aaa1f5e5e7ce0fc3ede71e7469"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-composition-rules.md",
      "decision": "由内容增长引出稳定、让位、联动及时间；跨触点失效直接改写规则前提，制作与交接的重复字段集中到工作台。",
      "sha256": "b2a7a4de7853ba6438d6ff05c00d2e39b2926128edf91a88709e74adca47a4bc"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-design-reasoning.md",
      "decision": "入口库集中维护入口、生成关系与十三项候选；删除重复资产、调性、组合和项目流程，保留七项专项边界细读。",
      "sha256": "bd44654db6655f64788a59467e12ca4719a6792e17a0f5a21c200a4e4efa795a"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-exploration-process.md",
      "decision": "流程只维护节奏、继续和回返条件；方向到资产的具体解释交给专题，过程字段集中维护。",
      "sha256": "16a8ebc6513fb5099e98af580641e89524d7e5aec1e0cbb96c8de63c65b6771d"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-framework.md",
      "decision": "框架只维护覆盖与依赖；专项推导交专题，早期版本修订和初始样本后置供回查。",
      "sha256": "328ac3e3ff1c72950e79fa4e7c90117b0b0021c27d5382e753724371468d7123"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-handoff.md",
      "decision": "整体重写新增转化稿：撤回三问同页、未知默认规则与不引用字重数量的跨越；当前教学使用已复看局部与既有条件方法，全部旧文保留。",
      "sha256": "5ea32abd24371ea33cb2588d92d0af28b7a547eeaee76a300ef0d84e6c7345c9"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-operation-library.md",
      "decision": "保留十四张完整可执行卡，避免去重损失武器细节；入口不再重复认知骨架与全流程。",
      "sha256": "dafd2363f2042651f118f1cee89db642cec321582c8c6470b4dcbc31967eeaed"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-thinking-routes.md",
      "decision": "保留八条品牌岔路和异题推演；通用比较与基准替换只维护在共同方法中。",
      "sha256": "6dfc5a01691dd6daea12951098b448a0c7a29e2b71a13b04b1ddeeb70c2a2072"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-typography-system.md",
      "decision": "保留上轮整体重写的职责；复核其上下游链接及术语，与本轮剩余专题接续。",
      "sha256": "6ce433f0f7c7ec87863b44b34cf6c65a365273eb89f28c7dcf55d4d5d89b8688"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-working-conclusions.md",
      "decision": "保留七条可用于取舍的判断；去掉重复工具总表，将新规则与检验范围写入原结论。",
      "sha256": "c47ac5de9e1b7124b5236a7a13aa0a458970e5aeadd4a01477f000c495ad6fe4"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/color-relations-perception.md",
      "decision": "保留全部作品分析与图像；具体案例前置，重复观察地图和词汇后置，色彩输出接到观看条件之后。",
      "sha256": "51339fb1b35ca288d455219bf12840801bbd140a955bc6f4ce956aa788228b55"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/commercial-art-development.md",
      "decision": "保留六条跨案例细读与来源；合并末尾逐批追加的叙事为内容职责和运行问题，调查进度交研究档案。",
      "sha256": "cec5bfbd1ef4466633435f65072b3345811a1e9a8128fe23550d837e5a00c3e0"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/form-meaning.md",
      "decision": "保留作品过程与语境解释；明确与A4的区别及到整体呈现的继续条件。",
      "sha256": "bab526361af6c4a8b1987f9b8f8d93ec3faeb4126742c65e4a3c0ff95e5376bb"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/index.md",
      "decision": "保留：总览只提供起步和选入口，不展开专项推导。",
      "sha256": "4dffd75b733906f9fed9f9bd7c3e8f6ee03ef7e27d8e69839440fcb37fbb0158"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/material-vi-derivation.md",
      "decision": "将纸的具体特征转译与误读留在专项；删除重复通用六环节和过程字段，由反馈连续引出操作、职责和迁移。",
      "sha256": "c0ac1426e4a47e7f9d89d9b589c81f8b939ec846124a16e633a6e1f4ff343cff"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/realm-conception.md",
      "decision": "保留源典与参与案例；明确整体呈现相对经验记录新增的决定。",
      "sha256": "4a1358384c02b191372dfbcad9b2ffc8ea33a699e8468b53199da0fe2323dd71"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/texture-material-perception.md",
      "decision": "从照片与局部变化引出生成维度；取消必须先定意图和普遍高级感配方，保留Memory及跨领域详细练习。",
      "sha256": "6c23ff9e1fa601615f24ccdd5c37b77ff6bb21f5ec5c3e96800b4efd3b7774cd"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/value-tonal-structure.md",
      "decision": "保留全部作品分析与图像；具体案例前置，重复观察地图和词汇后置，色彩输出接到观看条件之后。",
      "sha256": "aed8035b9e03a5449e5a6aa53b527c0dbf5022b279d3dc4c7cc56155bc439e79"
    }
  ],
  "archives": [
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/experience-question.md",
      "title": "A1 经验与问题",
      "file": "experience-question-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/form-relations.md",
      "title": "A2 形式与关系",
      "file": "form-relations-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/02-methods/observation-comparison.md",
      "title": "观察与比较方法",
      "file": "observation-comparison-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/02-methods/translation-generation.md",
      "title": "转译与生成方法",
      "file": "translation-generation-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/value-tonal-structure.md",
      "title": "明度与明暗结构：从黑白灰进入艺术的形式分析",
      "file": "value-tonal-structure-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/color-relations-perception.md",
      "title": "色彩关系：从相对知觉到画面组织",
      "file": "color-relations-perception-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/texture-material-perception.md",
      "title": "肌理与物质感知：从观看到审美判断",
      "file": "texture-material-perception-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/aesthetic-experience.md",
      "title": "审美经验",
      "file": "aesthetic-experience-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/form-meaning.md",
      "title": "形式与意味",
      "file": "form-meaning-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/realm-conception.md",
      "title": "境界与意境",
      "file": "realm-conception-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-tone-strategy.md",
      "title": "品牌调性：从切入点到完整表达方向",
      "file": "brand-tone-strategy-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-asset-derivation.md",
      "title": "品牌 VI 资产的推导与协调",
      "file": "brand-vi-asset-derivation-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-design-reasoning.md",
      "title": "品牌 VI 的切入点与设计方法库",
      "file": "brand-vi-design-reasoning-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-sensory-direction.md",
      "title": "从肌理与形式关系细化品牌感知方向",
      "file": "brand-sensory-direction-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-composition-rules.md",
      "title": "品牌 VI 的组合与变化规则",
      "file": "brand-vi-composition-rules-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/material-vi-derivation.md",
      "title": "从材料特征到品牌 VI 的推导与迭代",
      "file": "material-vi-derivation-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/03-applications/digital-surface.md",
      "title": "数字表面与Hero工作台",
      "file": "digital-surface-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-thinking-routes.md",
      "title": "品牌 VI 的思考策略与启发式路由",
      "file": "brand-vi-thinking-routes-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-operation-library.md",
      "title": "品牌 VI 策略与操作卡",
      "file": "brand-vi-operation-library-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-exploration-process.md",
      "title": "品牌 VI 的探索 推导与迭代流程",
      "file": "brand-vi-exploration-process-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-working-conclusions.md",
      "title": "品牌 VI 的阶段性认知与设计判断",
      "file": "brand-vi-working-conclusions-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/commercial-art-development.md",
      "title": "商业艺术的并行发展：形式、物件与体验",
      "file": "commercial-art-development-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-framework.md",
      "title": "品牌 VI 设计骨架研究稿",
      "file": "brand-vi-framework-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/01-learning/relations-to-expression.md",
      "title": "从观察与关系走向表达语言",
      "file": "relations-to-expression-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/01-learning/independent-project.md",
      "title": "自主课题与过程档案",
      "file": "independent-project-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/learning-path.md",
      "title": "美学渐进学习路径",
      "file": "learning-path-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/02-methods/index.md",
      "title": "美学方法与调用地图",
      "file": "aesthetics-02-methods-index-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/03-applications/brand-vi.md",
      "title": "品牌VI设计工作台",
      "file": "brand-vi-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/content-map.md",
      "title": "美学内容归位与补充顺序",
      "file": "content-map-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/00-structures/index.md",
      "title": "美学认知骨架",
      "file": "aesthetics-00-structures-index-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    },
    {
      "path": "aesthetics/brand-vi-handoff.md",
      "title": "从读到的结论到自己写的规定",
      "file": "brand-vi-handoff-before-continuity-review-2026-10-15.txt"
    }
  ],
  "effect_state": "编辑与依赖审查已完成；新练习及实际学习、阅读、接手效果仍待执行",
  "teaching_figure": {
    "path": "aesthetics/brand-tone-strategy.assets/relationship-choices.svg",
    "origin": "本项目原创教学假设，同问题不同关系及表达职责，不是案例原图或效果验证",
    "sha256": "c3436a44f0cad70b5c2a616997fc096b94248f1e2ef01d1c2e3e549772932ca7"
  }
}