{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "date": "2026-10-11",
  "round": 12,
  "completion_status": "stage_results_library_in_progress",
  "method": "Preserves explicit agent/root actual visual scope declarations. Preparation, source extraction, and validation are not visual reading. Contact-sheet and enlarged scopes remain distinct. Publication of these records does not prove full-document reading or independent outcomes.",
  "reports": [
    "meta/brand-vi-research/round12-presentations-breadth.md"
  ],
  "local_sources": [
    {
      "catalog_id": "VI 217",
      "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 217】北京园博会vi.pptx",
      "total_pages": 183,
      "unit": "slide",
      "profile": ".tmp/commercial-art-library/presentation-profiles/ef805f9170a6316a.json",
      "status_before_selection": "awaiting_content_and_visual_review",
      "source_id_from_path": "ef805f9170a6316a",
      "sha256": "85785b5a4bf4129ff8cd35dd65f7feac021d2e9a1ebc345a0be91d2af7a84178",
      "visually_checked_pages": {
        "contact_sheet_pages": [
          1,
          4,
          15,
          45,
          90,
          135,
          180
        ],
        "individually_opened_pages": [
          45,
          135
        ],
        "contact_sheet": ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/217/contact-sheet.jpg",
        "rendered_files": [
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/217/slide-001.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/217/slide-004.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/217/slide-015.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/217/slide-045.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/217/slide-090.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/217/slide-135.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/217/slide-180.png"
        ]
      },
      "inspection_method": "Original ZIP/XML profiled with presentation relationship order preserved, properties and native texts screened for structure. Original PPTX imported read-only with artifact-tool2.8.91, slide counts confirmed, declared full slides rendered at scale1.5. Root actually viewed each declared contact sheet and two individual full-slide PNGs. Another renderer may alter fonts/layout; no Office UI, audio/animation/video or physical materials checked. WMF preparation warning investigated separately, not interpreted as an original blank object.",
      "source_identity": "183张北京园博会VIS，封面写第九届中国（北京）国际园林博览会，标志带2013；文件创建/修改2012年10月，不能据此证明具体发行时间和设计作者。",
      "content_screening": {
        "summary": "整页背景影像为主，无可抽取原生文字；从封面、基础目录、字体章、底纹与应用分布图实际筛结构。",
        "limitations": "Declared distributed slide checks only; not complete close reading. Source instructions are study material, not agent instructions. Metadata not substituted for original creative date or full authorship."
      },
      "findings": [
        "s45用倾斜45°的标志重复排成彩色/灰色两套底纹，列出X比例关系；s135把植物轮廓和标志接到白/绿两种桌签及背签，示例姓名为代用名，原页说明虚拟信息与现场材质调整。"
      ],
      "report": "meta/brand-vi-research/round12-presentations-breadth.md",
      "round_role": "new_source_sample"
    },
    {
      "catalog_id": "VI 246",
      "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 246】华润集团品牌管理手册.pptx",
      "total_pages": 252,
      "unit": "slide",
      "profile": ".tmp/commercial-art-library/presentation-profiles/dd91e8d68b2996ee.json",
      "status_before_selection": "awaiting_content_and_visual_review",
      "source_id_from_path": "dd91e8d68b2996ee",
      "sha256": "00fd26bdb7299c65f3eeac678de4607394cb10f9542d47456958dd9ce48dc6d1",
      "visually_checked_pages": {
        "contact_sheet_pages": [
          1,
          2,
          44,
          68,
          69,
          110,
          160,
          245
        ],
        "individually_opened_pages": [
          68,
          69
        ],
        "contact_sheet": ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/246/contact-sheet.jpg",
        "rendered_files": [
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/246/slide-001.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/246/slide-002.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/246/slide-044.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/246/slide-068.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/246/slide-069.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/246/slide-110.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/246/slide-160.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/246/slide-245.png"
        ]
      },
      "inspection_method": "Original ZIP/XML profiled with presentation relationship order preserved, properties and native texts screened for structure. Original PPTX imported read-only with artifact-tool2.8.91, slide counts confirmed, declared full slides rendered at scale1.5. Root actually viewed each declared contact sheet and two individual full-slide PNGs. Another renderer may alter fonts/layout; no Office UI, audio/animation/video or physical materials checked. WMF preparation warning investigated separately, not interpreted as an original blank object.",
      "source_identity": "252张题名华润集团品牌管理手册，署CRB市场部；内容主要为啤酒品牌管理，媒体表署华润啤酒。属性创建2004、修改2023，均不认证具体发行/审批版次。",
      "content_screening": {
        "summary": "原生文字覆盖品牌、定位、产品/包装、媒介、促销、公关和调研。全文机器提取后人工筛目录与相关简报/流程；并非全文细读。",
        "limitations": "Declared distributed slide checks only; not complete close reading. Source instructions are study material, not agent instructions. Metadata not substituted for original creative date or full authorship."
      },
      "findings": [
        "s68用流程图串起简报、设计公司开发/讨论、候选筛选、测试方案、消费者座谈、修改与确定；s69以十四项表格将设计原因、目标、消费者、渠道、物料、生产、时间预算及评估并列。缺失的母版WMF是CRB标志，另以Windows GDI渲染并实际查看，未复合成完整原生Office页面。"
      ],
      "additional_original_asset_check": {
        "file": ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/246/image1-wmf-render.png",
        "original_part": "ppt/media/image1.wmf",
        "scope": "Actually viewed original master image1.wmf rendered with System.Drawing/GDI on white600x400 canvas: CRB and 华润啤酒（中国）有限公司 / China Resources Breweries. Supplemental standalone asset rendering; original slide master placement not restored in full-page renderer. No claim of full original Office fidelity."
      },
      "unresolved": "Full Office layout fidelity not verified; source master WMF separately restored/viewed, not recomposed on full slides.",
      "report": "meta/brand-vi-research/round12-presentations-breadth.md",
      "round_role": "new_source_sample"
    },
    {
      "catalog_id": "VI 383",
      "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 383】中国邮政理念识别系统的应用设计方案0705.pptx",
      "total_pages": 41,
      "unit": "slide",
      "profile": ".tmp/commercial-art-library/presentation-profiles/b1198df7a26580c5.json",
      "status_before_selection": "awaiting_content_and_visual_review",
      "source_id_from_path": "b1198df7a26580c5",
      "sha256": "c387ae743fb9ec69ce3ade0fbca453a75f06b53778e3e8ffb8c2900be938d87a",
      "visually_checked_pages": {
        "contact_sheet_pages": [
          1,
          2,
          9,
          17,
          19,
          28,
          33,
          41
        ],
        "individually_opened_pages": [
          19,
          33
        ],
        "contact_sheet": ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/383/contact-sheet.jpg",
        "rendered_files": [
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/383/slide-001.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/383/slide-002.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/383/slide-009.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/383/slide-017.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/383/slide-019.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/383/slide-028.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/383/slide-033.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/383/slide-041.png"
        ]
      },
      "inspection_method": "Original ZIP/XML profiled with presentation relationship order preserved, properties and native texts screened for structure. Original PPTX imported read-only with artifact-tool2.8.91, slide counts confirmed, declared full slides rendered at scale1.5. Root actually viewed each declared contact sheet and two individual full-slide PNGs. Another renderer may alter fonts/layout; no Office UI, audio/animation/video or physical materials checked. WMF preparation warning investigated separately, not interpreted as an original blank object.",
      "source_identity": "41张中国邮政理念识别系统应用规范/方案，正文面向理念文字的墙面与展示应用，不当成完整邮政VI；创建2015-07-05、修改2015-07-15，个人字段仅属性。",
      "content_screening": {
        "summary": "原生文字41张，前半应用原则、后半比例、多语言、边框、字体、色彩与材料。",
        "limitations": "Declared distributed slide checks only; not complete close reading. Source instructions are study material, not agent instructions. Metadata not substituted for original creative date or full authorship."
      },
      "findings": [
        "s19上方蒙古文纵向字形与下方中文理念语配为一个比例框，标出净空；s33用银灰框/灰底绿字和绿底黄字两幅透视样图说明有底有框式。文字译意和现场采用未验证。"
      ],
      "report": "meta/brand-vi-research/round12-presentations-breadth.md",
      "round_role": "new_source_sample"
    },
    {
      "catalog_id": "VI 477",
      "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 477】Skyworth_template -2m2design.pptx",
      "total_pages": 122,
      "unit": "slide",
      "profile": ".tmp/commercial-art-library/presentation-profiles/9b10b6f6103db48c.json",
      "status_before_selection": "awaiting_content_and_visual_review",
      "source_id_from_path": "9b10b6f6103db48c",
      "sha256": "34587986f55635ceee19e1a3e33b88e96263ab2f82ed606988bd703f62fa0bbc",
      "visually_checked_pages": {
        "contact_sheet_pages": [
          3,
          29,
          48,
          60,
          66,
          98,
          111,
          121
        ],
        "individually_opened_pages": [
          48,
          66
        ],
        "contact_sheet": ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/477/contact-sheet.jpg",
        "rendered_files": [
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/477/slide-003.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/477/slide-029.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/477/slide-048.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/477/slide-060.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/477/slide-066.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/477/slide-098.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/477/slide-111.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/477/slide-121.png"
        ]
      },
      "inspection_method": "Original ZIP/XML profiled with presentation relationship order preserved, properties and native texts screened for structure. Original PPTX imported read-only with artifact-tool2.8.91, slide counts confirmed, declared full slides rendered at scale1.5. Root actually viewed each declared contact sheet and two individual full-slide PNGs. Another renderer may alter fonts/layout; no Office UI, audio/animation/video or physical materials checked. WMF preparation warning investigated separately, not interpreted as an original blank object.",
      "source_identity": "122张创维品牌方案/指南，页内2018-03-30 Brand Center，页脚Designed by2M2DESIGN；s92/98/121保留需调整/缺示例备注。按含工作中备注的方案读取，不推为最终批准版。",
      "content_screening": {
        "summary": "文字章节涵盖基础、字体、摄影、广告、包装、办公、导视、联署和子公司；部分整页图片不能靠原生文字了解，结合实际分布图。",
        "limitations": "Declared distributed slide checks only; not complete close reading. Source instructions are study material, not agent instructions. Metadata not substituted for original creative date or full authorship."
      },
      "findings": [
        "s48深灰长场右端蓝条用a/2、a/4、a/8、a/32及MAX/Mini线标变化幅度；s66竖式电视广告覆盖蓝网格并用引线把标志、标题、二级信息、产品内外创意区和公司信息分开。"
      ],
      "report": "meta/brand-vi-research/round12-presentations-breadth.md",
      "round_role": "new_source_sample"
    },
    {
      "catalog_id": "VI 725",
      "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 725】急急脚咖啡品牌手册.pptx",
      "total_pages": 51,
      "unit": "slide",
      "profile": ".tmp/commercial-art-library/presentation-profiles/ec713920d33f5a6e.json",
      "status_before_selection": "awaiting_content_and_visual_review",
      "source_id_from_path": "ec713920d33f5a6e",
      "sha256": "e5bbe9c08fb1714497cae7e95612baa230e9cfd1d1ba4742e9ff8b70333717b2",
      "visually_checked_pages": {
        "contact_sheet_pages": [
          4,
          12,
          25,
          33,
          36,
          44,
          49
        ],
        "individually_opened_pages": [
          25,
          33
        ],
        "contact_sheet": ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/725/contact-sheet.jpg",
        "rendered_files": [
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/725/slide-004.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/725/slide-012.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/725/slide-025.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/725/slide-033.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/725/slide-036.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/725/slide-044.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/725/slide-049.png"
        ]
      },
      "inspection_method": "Original ZIP/XML profiled with presentation relationship order preserved, properties and native texts screened for structure. Original PPTX imported read-only with artifact-tool2.8.91, slide counts confirmed, declared full slides rendered at scale1.5. Root actually viewed each declared contact sheet and two individual full-slide PNGs. Another renderer may alter fonts/layout; no Office UI, audio/animation/video or physical materials checked. WMF preparation warning investigated separately, not interpreted as an original blank object.",
      "source_identity": "51张急急脚fastfoot咖啡介绍/合作资料，页面版权2022；创建2019、修改2022不自动解释产品推出日期，未核个人创作署名。",
      "content_screening": {
        "summary": "内容涵盖品牌、门店、产品、社媒、合作与资金计划，区别于纯VI规范。",
        "limitations": "Declared distributed slide checks only; not complete close reading. Source instructions are study material, not agent instructions. Metadata not substituted for original creative date or full authorship."
      },
      "findings": [
        "s25红/黄放射线、格纹和撕纸式白边连接糖水咖啡海报；单品用不同底色/食材名称区分。s33并列倒咖啡静帧截图、黄底产品帖与绿底发布会插画，品牌绿贯穿但内容形式各异；未播放截图对应视频。"
      ],
      "report": "meta/brand-vi-research/round12-presentations-breadth.md",
      "round_role": "new_source_sample"
    },
    {
      "catalog_id": "VI 745",
      "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 745】基础部分A.pptx",
      "total_pages": 25,
      "unit": "slide",
      "profile": ".tmp/commercial-art-library/presentation-profiles/7e8fca95b86f14c6.json",
      "status_before_selection": "awaiting_content_and_visual_review",
      "source_id_from_path": "7e8fca95b86f14c6",
      "sha256": "71958eaba01d018795097d35c416d076a09746ef607a32167fea39d88feb28a0",
      "visually_checked_pages": {
        "contact_sheet_pages": [
          1,
          3,
          6,
          13,
          18,
          21,
          24
        ],
        "individually_opened_pages": [
          18,
          24
        ],
        "contact_sheet": ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/745/contact-sheet.jpg",
        "rendered_files": [
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/745/slide-001.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/745/slide-003.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/745/slide-006.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/745/slide-013.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/745/slide-018.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/745/slide-021.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/745/slide-024.png"
        ]
      },
      "inspection_method": "Original ZIP/XML profiled with presentation relationship order preserved, properties and native texts screened for structure. Original PPTX imported read-only with artifact-tool2.8.91, slide counts confirmed, declared full slides rendered at scale1.5. Root actually viewed each declared contact sheet and two individual full-slide PNGs. Another renderer may alter fonts/layout; no Office UI, audio/animation/video or physical materials checked. WMF preparation warning investigated separately, not interpreted as an original blank object.",
      "source_identity": "25张京东金融视觉形象识别手册A基础，封面确定对象，文件名仅基础部分A；属性修改2015-12-28，元数据王靖不足以证明完整创作名单。与VI821 B应用为同一身份不同分册，保留内容互补关系。",
      "content_screening": {
        "summary": "基础目录涵盖标志、标准字、颜色与辅助图形；文字层多为目录/页号，主体图需实际查看。",
        "limitations": "Declared distributed slide checks only; not complete close reading. Source instructions are study material, not agent instructions. Metadata not substituted for original creative date or full authorship."
      },
      "findings": [
        "s18银色三维犬形吉祥物标出半身裁切区；s24以九宫格展示线描半身在红/灰/蓝/橙/绿等底色的反白/红线变化。保留具体例图，不从屏幕样张推为已制造银色物件。"
      ],
      "report": "meta/brand-vi-research/round12-presentations-breadth.md",
      "round_role": "new_source_sample"
    },
    {
      "catalog_id": "VI 813",
      "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 813】中国茶品牌-品牌视觉升级策划案【VI设计】【视觉更新】.pptx",
      "total_pages": 79,
      "unit": "slide",
      "profile": ".tmp/commercial-art-library/presentation-profiles/2db4a5a57795162b.json",
      "status_before_selection": "awaiting_content_and_visual_review",
      "source_id_from_path": "2db4a5a57795162b",
      "sha256": "01d74821279351fa1b209ba9a6d4696ce181745b31c510369cdb516237035918",
      "visually_checked_pages": {
        "contact_sheet_pages": [
          1,
          4,
          14,
          28,
          40,
          58,
          76
        ],
        "individually_opened_pages": [
          58,
          76
        ],
        "contact_sheet": ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/813/contact-sheet.jpg",
        "rendered_files": [
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/813/slide-001.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/813/slide-004.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/813/slide-014.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/813/slide-028.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/813/slide-040.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/813/slide-058.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/813/slide-076.png"
        ]
      },
      "inspection_method": "Original ZIP/XML profiled with presentation relationship order preserved, properties and native texts screened for structure. Original PPTX imported read-only with artifact-tool2.8.91, slide counts confirmed, declared full slides rendered at scale1.5. Root actually viewed each declared contact sheet and two individual full-slide PNGs. Another renderer may alter fonts/layout; no Office UI, audio/animation/video or physical materials checked. WMF preparation warning investigated separately, not interpreted as an original blank object.",
      "source_identity": "79张唐羽品牌视觉升级提案，文件名泛称中国茶品牌，封面确定唐羽；所看页出现方案壹，未取得最终采用或作者署名。创建/修改2024-09仅为属性。",
      "content_screening": {
        "summary": "全部为无原生文字的整页背景图，实际分布检查定位、参考空间、方案段及图形/应用；不把空文字层视为无内容。",
        "limitations": "Declared distributed slide checks only; not complete close reading. Source instructions are study material, not agent instructions. Metadata not substituted for original creative date or full authorship."
      },
      "findings": [
        "s58将茶叶照片、修行人物和行楷书法用加号连接，右边等号后为三块灰色候选轮廓；s76双面竖名片把三块黑形、红小印与唐羽名称放在米色面，背面浅褐底以成组细线回环。参考人物/书法具体作者未核。"
      ],
      "report": "meta/brand-vi-research/round12-presentations-breadth.md",
      "round_role": "new_source_sample"
    },
    {
      "catalog_id": "VI 821",
      "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 821】应用部分B修改最终20160202.pptx",
      "total_pages": 61,
      "unit": "slide",
      "profile": ".tmp/commercial-art-library/presentation-profiles/7c829e2dc3f1a468.json",
      "status_before_selection": "awaiting_content_and_visual_review",
      "source_id_from_path": "7c829e2dc3f1a468",
      "sha256": "71e72254b4935218ab6144e94e243f41014fb5115941cd4e578f560e7af51797",
      "visually_checked_pages": {
        "contact_sheet_pages": [
          1,
          10,
          19,
          24,
          38,
          45,
          50,
          60
        ],
        "individually_opened_pages": [
          10,
          45
        ],
        "contact_sheet": ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/821/contact-sheet.jpg",
        "rendered_files": [
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/821/slide-001.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/821/slide-010.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/821/slide-019.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/821/slide-024.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/821/slide-038.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/821/slide-045.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/821/slide-050.png",
          ".tmp/commercial-art-round12/presentations/821/slide-060.png"
        ]
      },
      "inspection_method": "Original ZIP/XML profiled with presentation relationship order preserved, properties and native texts screened for structure. Original PPTX imported read-only with artifact-tool2.8.91, slide counts confirmed, declared full slides rendered at scale1.5. Root actually viewed each declared contact sheet and two individual full-slide PNGs. Another renderer may alter fonts/layout; no Office UI, audio/animation/video or physical materials checked. WMF preparation warning investigated separately, not interpreted as an original blank object.",
      "source_identity": "61张京东金融B应用分册，标题/应用页与VI745明确同品牌且分工相接，文件名修改最终不证明全部页定稿；属性创建2016-01-21、修改2016-02-01，另有调整备注。",
      "content_screening": {
        "summary": "目录分办公物料和标志应用，含纸杯、压印/金属粘印示意、数字版面、产品组合、二维码、线下不同幅面；并非完整实际交付样本。",
        "limitations": "Declared distributed slide checks only; not complete close reading. Source instructions are study material, not agent instructions. Metadata not substituted for original creative date or full authorship."
      },
      "findings": [
        "s10纸杯正反视图标出轮廓尺寸，正面小组合标和大线描犬形，背面二维码；s45竖幅模板把组合标放左上、二维码左下和网址右下，红虚线分解版面留白及相对尺寸。正文/图示局部比例不同仍待核，不拼成一条确定规则。"
      ],
      "unresolved": "s45 printed text and diagram differ on combination-logo minimum-width and top-inset reference. Preserve both; no unified final ratio inferred.",
      "report": "meta/brand-vi-research/round12-presentations-breadth.md",
      "round_role": "new_source_sample"
    }
  ],
  "web_sources": [],
  "topic_evidence": {
    "presentations": {
      "schema_version": 1,
      "date": "2026-10-11",
      "round": "round12-presentations-breadth",
      "method": "Original ZIP/XML profiled with presentation relationship order preserved, properties and native texts screened for structure. Original PPTX imported read-only with artifact-tool2.8.91, slide counts confirmed, declared full slides rendered at scale1.5. Root actually viewed each declared contact sheet and two individual full-slide PNGs. Another renderer may alter fonts/layout; no Office UI, audio/animation/video or physical materials checked. WMF preparation warning investigated separately, not interpreted as an original blank object."
    }
  },
  "independent_audits": [
    {
      "report": "meta/brand-vi-research/round12-audit.md",
      "evidence": {
        "schema_version": 1,
        "round": "round12-independent-audit",
        "date": "2026-10-11",
        "method": "Independently opened existing per-slide PNGs at original resolution with view_image. Images are the saved artifact-tool renderings from the prior round, not a fresh Office render. This audit records only the individual slide pages actually opened here; prior report/contact-sheet views are not attributed to this audit. No web sources, animation, video playback, original Office UI or physical installations checked.",
        "local_sources": [
          {
            "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 217】北京园博会vi.pptx",
            "total_pages": 183,
            "visually_checked_pages": [
              45
            ],
            "rendered_files": [
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\217\\slide-045.png"
            ],
            "inspection_method": "Opened the existing rendered slide-045.png at original resolution using view_image; visual second-look only, not a fresh Office render.",
            "findings": [
              "p45 presents the tilted repeated Expo mark as separate standard-color and gray spot-color pattern fields. A 45-degree reference and X-based spacing values are visibly diagrammed.",
              "This supports a formal description of repetition, direction and spacing, not measured legibility, recall, or on-site performance."
            ],
            "source_identity": "Selection/report identify VI217 as the Beijing Garden Expo visual identity system; the checked page itself is a VIS auxiliary-pattern specification page and does not independently confirm full authorship or project identity.",
            "content_screening": "This was a targeted visual page check, not a complete deck review."
          },
          {
            "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 246】华润集团品牌管理手册.pptx",
            "total_pages": 252,
            "visually_checked_pages": [
              68,
              69
            ],
            "rendered_files": [
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\246\\slide-068.png",
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\246\\slide-069.png"
            ],
            "inspection_method": "Opened existing rendered slide-068.png and slide-069.png at original resolution with view_image. Also separately opened the previously prepared standalone GDI output image1-wmf-render.png; it was not composited into either slide.",
            "findings": [
              "p68 visibly maps the packaging brief, discussion/design-company development, initial candidate screening, research plan, consumer panel, revisions and product-package decision; a bottom note cautions against letting consumers dictate the design style.",
              "p69 is a legible fourteen-question packaging-design brief, including background, objectives, brand positioning, consumers/competitors, channels, use, production limits, timing/budget and evaluation.",
              "A generic missing-image icon is visible at the upper left of p68 while a Hua Run mark appears at upper right. The detached WMF render shows a separate CRB mark and bilingual China Resources Breweries name. The detached image does not independently establish full-page master placement, scale, crop or compositing."
            ],
            "source_identity": "The selected deck title names China Resources; p68 references CRB and the visible page header shows Hua Run branding. The separately viewed WMF contains CRB and the company name. Exact original Office master composition was not verified.",
            "content_screening": "Targeted review of two related process pages plus one detached media rendering; not a complete deck review.",
            "supplemental_rendered_file": "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\246\\image1-wmf-render.png"
          },
          {
            "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 383】中国邮政理念识别系统的应用设计方案0705.pptx",
            "total_pages": 41,
            "visually_checked_pages": [
              19,
              28
            ],
            "rendered_files": [
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\383\\slide-019.png",
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\383\\slide-028.png"
            ],
            "inspection_method": "Opened existing rendered slide-019.png and slide-028.png at original resolution with view_image. No translation validation or Office re-render.",
            "findings": [
              "p19 labels itself 2.3.1 Mongolian proportion diagram; vertically arranged Mongolian lettering sits above the Chinese slogan inside dashed and green proportional frames.",
              "p28 labels itself 2.3.4 Uyghur proportion diagram; the Uyghur-script line sits above the Chinese slogan within a proportional frame. The page supplies the language label; this check does not validate translation or reading comprehension."
            ],
            "source_identity": "Selection/report identify the deck as a China Post concept-identity application proposal. Checked slides identify the content as the application rules for the concept-identity system.",
            "content_screening": "Targeted review of two language/proportion pages; not a full review of the 41-slide deck."
          },
          {
            "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 477】Skyworth_template -2m2design.pptx",
            "total_pages": 122,
            "visually_checked_pages": [
              98,
              121
            ],
            "rendered_files": [
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\477\\slide-098.png",
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\477\\slide-121.png"
            ],
            "inspection_method": "Opened existing rendered slide-098.png and slide-121.png at original resolution with view_image. Render artifacts were not checked against Office UI.",
            "findings": [
              "p98 states that office materials need adjustment, requests usable office versions and associated electronic examples (including PPT, email and contract/Word formats), and requests printing proofs and process samples for printed material.",
              "p121 says subsidiary-company application examples are still missing and proposes using a cooperative subsidiary as a demonstration, listing signage, building, office and digital media.",
              "p121 footer credits and web address visibly overlap in this rendered image; without Office UI this may be a conversion/layout artifact and should not be presented as a designed feature."
            ],
            "source_identity": "The checked page footer identifies Skyworth Brand Guidelines and Designed by 2M2DESIGN; this is a working guide with visibly stated follow-up needs, not proof that every listed example was delivered.",
            "content_screening": "Targeted review of two production-note pages; not a full review of the 122-slide deck."
          },
          {
            "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 725】急急脚咖啡品牌手册.pptx",
            "total_pages": 51,
            "visually_checked_pages": [
              33
            ],
            "rendered_files": [
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\725\\slide-033.png"
            ],
            "inspection_method": "Opened existing rendered slide-033.png at original resolution with view_image. Did not access or play any linked video.",
            "findings": [
              "p33 juxtaposes a static coffee-making social-media screenshot with an illustrated press-conference graphic and a static product post. The image includes mobile/social interface details but is not video playback.",
              "The page's claims about lively, shareable content are brand-document statements, not independently measured audience effects."
            ],
            "source_identity": "Page header names fastfoot and 急急脚咖啡公司; footer carries a 2022 copyright line.",
            "content_screening": "One targeted social-media/application slide; not a full deck review."
          },
          {
            "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 745】基础部分A.pptx",
            "total_pages": 25,
            "visually_checked_pages": [
              18
            ],
            "rendered_files": [
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\745\\slide-018.png"
            ],
            "inspection_method": "Opened existing rendered slide-018.png at original resolution with view_image; no physical product verification.",
            "findings": [
              "The JD Finance page shows a metallic three-dimensional dog-shaped auxiliary graphic with the upper 2/3X region marked for half-body cropping and the lower area separated by a construction grid. This is a diagram/rendered sample, not proof of a manufactured object."
            ],
            "source_identity": "The visible page header says JD Finance Visual Identity Guidelines and Basic part - Supplementary graphics.",
            "content_screening": "One targeted auxiliary-graphic page; not a full review of the 25-slide deck."
          },
          {
            "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 813】中国茶品牌-品牌视觉升级策划案【VI设计】【视觉更新】.pptx",
            "total_pages": 79,
            "visually_checked_pages": [
              40,
              58,
              76
            ],
            "rendered_files": [
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\813\\slide-040.png",
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\813\\slide-058.png",
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\813\\slide-076.png"
            ],
            "inspection_method": "Opened existing rendered slide-040.png, slide-058.png and slide-076.png at original resolution using view_image; no Office re-render and no external authorship research.",
            "findings": [
              "p40 is a section divider labeled 方案壹, providing direct support for treating the following material as a proposal option.",
              "p58 says the graphic transforms and combines tea with cultivation/practice using regular-script calligraphic strokes; its three input columns are labeled tea leaves, a person practicing, and regular-script calligraphy, with gray candidate forms after an equals sign.",
              "p76 shows a two-sided vertical business-card mockup, with dark forms, a red seal and Tang Yu name on the light front, and a brown field with fine looped line motifs on the reverse. Source, authorship and adoption remain unverified."
            ],
            "source_identity": "Page p76 visibly says TANG YU / 唐羽; p40 visibly identifies a 方案壹 section. This supports a Tang Yu proposal sample, not proof of final adoption.",
            "content_screening": "Targeted proposal-divider, concept-rationale and application-page review; not a full 79-slide deck review."
          },
          {
            "absolute_path": "D:\\BaiduNetdiskDownload\\【刘sir】1000+品牌手册阅览室\\1.【总包】1000+品牌手册合集\\【手册VI 821】应用部分B修改最终20160202.pptx",
            "total_pages": 61,
            "visually_checked_pages": [
              45
            ],
            "rendered_files": [
              "C:\\Users\\sebsl\\.codex\\worktrees\\a2fc\\world-map\\.tmp\\commercial-art-round12\\presentations\\821\\slide-045.png"
            ],
            "inspection_method": "Opened existing rendered slide-045.png at original resolution with view_image. Compared the visible body copy, diagram and bottom X/Y definition; no Office re-render.",
            "findings": [
              "The body text specifies combination-logo width greater than 0.4X and top offset greater than 0.025X. The diagram labels the width greater than 0.3X and top offset greater than 0.025Y; the page defines X as width and Y as height.",
              "These are visible internal annotation conflicts. Do not normalize them into one final ratio or silently select the text or diagram as authoritative."
            ],
            "source_identity": "Visible header says JD Finance Visual Identity Guidelines / Application part. This is the B application booklet and complements, rather than creates a second brand identity beside, the VI745 basic booklet.",
            "content_screening": "One targeted page with a documented internal inconsistency; not a full deck review."
          }
        ],
        "web_sources": [],
        "unresolved": [
          "No source was reopened in native Office UI during this independent pass; all page observations describe the saved renderer output.",
          "VI246 detached WMF rendering was viewed but not recomposed in the master/layout, so original full-slide placement and Office fidelity remain unverified.",
          "No adoption, production, in-situ legibility, recall, translation correctness, user testing or campaign effectiveness claims were verified."
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "totals": {
    "local_source_files": 8,
    "new_source_files": 8,
    "recovered_and_rechecked_files": 0,
    "unique_cited_web_urls": 0
  }
}
